Selling on Etsy isn’t just about great products. It’s also about being honest with buyers. Clear and truthful marketing helps people trust your shop and helps you stay within Etsy’s rules and the law.
Etsy recently shared guidance about advertising, sales, and discounts. Here’s what it means for you, in plain English.
Quick note before we start
If you sell on Etsy, you must follow Etsy’s policies and the consumer protection laws that apply to your country and your buyers’ countries.
This article is for education only. It’s not legal advice. If you’re unsure about your situation, it’s always best to talk to a lawyer.
Why honest advertising matters
Etsy is a global marketplace. That means buyers can come from many different countries, all with different laws. Even though the rules can change depending on where you sell, the main ideas are always the same:
- Be honest
- Be clear
- Be fair
Following these principles helps you:
- Build long-term trust with buyers
- Avoid confusing or misleading shoppers
- Stay aligned with Etsy’s rules and the law
Be truthful and accurate in your listings
Everything you say about your product should be true and easy to understand.
Make sure you can back up your claims
If you say something about your product, it must be true and provable. This applies to your Etsy listing and anywhere else you promote your product.
Describe your product clearly
Your photos, videos, titles, and descriptions should match the real product.
- Be honest about materials, quality, and condition
- If you edit photos, don’t change how the product actually looks
- Don’t hide flaws or make the item look better than it is
Use precise language
Words matter. For example:
- If something is gold-plated, say gold-plated
- Don’t call it “gold jewelry” if it’s not solid gold
Vague or misleading wording can confuse buyers and may break Etsy’s rules.
Don’t mislead buyers (even by accident)
Avoid wording or pricing that makes a product seem better or cheaper than it really is.
Things to avoid:
- Big claims that suggest higher quality than the item actually has
- Leaving out important details that could affect a buyer’s decision
When in doubt, explain more, not less.
Don’t try to game Etsy’s system
You’re not allowed to manipulate Etsy features to make a deal look better than it really is.
This includes playing with:
- Price history
- Sale timing
- Discounts
- Reviews or listings
For example, raising a price just to mark it down later or to trigger countdown timers or “sale” badges can break Etsy’s rules and cause legal issues.
Rules for sales and discounts
Avoid constant sales
A sale should be temporary and special.
You must actually sell your item at its regular price for a reasonable amount of time and in reasonable quantities.
If an item is almost always “on sale,” the discounted price may legally be considered the real price. From a buyer’s point of view, a sale should feel limited, not permanent.
Don’t use fake discounts
Any discount based on a “previous price” must show real savings.
Strikethrough pricing
If you show something like $100 → $50:
- The $100 must be the real regular price
- The item must have been sold at that price for a meaningful time
- You can’t raise prices briefly just to create a fake sale
“Up to” discounts
If you advertise “Up to 50% off”:
- A real number of items must actually be close to 50% off
- The claim must stay true for the whole sale
If only one slow-selling item is deeply discounted and most others aren’t, that can be misleading.
Reviews must be real
Reviews are about trust, and trust only works if feedback is honest.
You may not:
- Write fake reviews
- Ask others to write fake reviews for you
- Offer rewards or discounts for positive reviews
These actions break Etsy’s Anti-Shilling Policy and can also break the law.
Final takeaway
Honest marketing protects your shop.
Clear product descriptions, real discounts, and genuine reviews help buyers trust you and help you avoid problems with Etsy. If a deal or claim feels “a little too clever,” it’s probably better to simplify and be upfront.
Trust grows when buyers know exactly what they’re getting—and that’s good for your shop in the long run.
Sources and Further Reading
Etsy Policies & Rules
- Understanding Truthful Advertising and Discount Practices https://www.etsy.com/seller-handbook/article/1450964704111
- Etsy Policies (main hub)
https://www.etsy.com/legal/policy/ - Etsy Seller Policy
https://www.etsy.com/legal/sellers/ - Etsy Advertising Policy
https://www.etsy.com/legal/advertising/ - Etsy Pricing & Fees Policy
https://www.etsy.com/legal/fees/ - Etsy Anti-Shilling Policy (Reviews & Fake Reviews)
https://www.etsy.com/legal/policy/shilling/243317364583
Consumer Protection & Legal Context
- U.S. Federal Trade Commission – Advertising Rules
https://www.ftc.gov/business-guidance/advertising-marketing - FTC Guidance on Deceptive Pricing
https://www.ftc.gov/business-guidance/resources/advertising-pricing - EU Consumer Protection Rules (if selling to EU buyers)
https://commission.europa.eu/consumer-protection_en
Etsy Help Resources (Seller Education)
- Etsy Seller Handbook
https://www.etsy.com/seller-handbook - Etsy Help Center
https://help.etsy.com/
Want your shop converting and in good standing?
Listadum scores every listing and shows you exactly what to fix, ranked by impact.
Start free · no credit card · connect your real Etsy shop in minutes
Related: Etsy’s 2025 Seller Updates: New Algorithms, Fees, and Gifting